Am I an oxymoron?
Dame Kiri said
that all Maori are lazy at home on the dole. That means
I'm not really Maori, right? Can a sickly brown liberal
ever live up to the standards of the Hongi Snobs? Am I
doomed to forever dwell on the Faux Iwi fringes?
Whanau today face the dilemma of raising tamariki
in a Jihad vs. McWorld diaspora of traditional collective
tikanga vs. modern atomised western life. Modern models
of success are anathema to our culture — yet economic
achievement is critical to our future. We must begin by examining the essentials of
who we are. Where we are from.
Where we grew up. Go back to the Ahi Kaa, and commence
a process of reconciliation. Who am I?
I am Leo Koziol, and I am from Nuhaka. Welcome
to my world.
* * * *
Over the past year and a half, I've been posting discussive
essays and articles on the future of Aotearoa New Zealand
in the 21st Century. Given the recent inflammation of
debate on national identity and race relations in our
country, my decision to commence such a narrative seems
remarkably prescient. At the heart of what I have been
writing about is an exploration of the notion of "Sense
of Place"
-- the shared experience of living in a unique, remote
and somewhat "alien" part of the world; New
Zealand's place in the world, in particular our "identity"
and "presence" in the America-driven global
media matrix. The shared history of our immigrant Maori
and Pakeha peoples, a shared history written on the land
in blood, toil, sweat. soul and spirit.
I write from Nuhaka, the small East Coast rural settlement
where I was born, and where I lived out my childhood and
teen years. Nuhaka to me seems to be the nexus of the
remainder of a relatively untouched and undeveloped coastal
landscape fast disappearing in the northern half of Te
Ika a Maui, the North Island of New Zealand. This place
is special. This place is authentic.
I view this part of our land as the "Spirit Coast",
stretching from depressed Opotiki, to depressed Wairoa
(and perhaps on further to depressed Wairarapa). In some
ways, it could be argued that economic depression in this
part of the nation is what has enabled local iwi (tribes)
and hapu (subtribes) to retain their identity and their
soul. The cultural changes that come with economic development
-- such as the presence of large amounts of foreign tourists
-- are still yet to make a significant impact.
A geography of genealogy stretches the Kahungunu tribe
from Mahia and Nuhaka -- the meeting place of Rongomaiwahine
and Kahungunu -- down to Ahuriri (Napier) and Heretaunga
(Hastings), across the Takapau plains and further onwards
along the coast to Porangahou and the Wairarapa. A geographical
expanse rivaled only by Ngai Tahu in the South Island
(Te Wai Pounamu).
Rongomaiwahine and Kahungunu came together in the lands
around Nuhaka. This is a tribal birthplace with new values
that were singularly indigenous to these lands. A connection
of wairua and whanaungatanga took place here that marked
a shift away from the warfaring of previous tribes. The
Kahungunu mantra was indeed "Make Love, Not War."
The descendants of these two eminent ancestors have intermingled,
but are yet to become one. At Mahia, the people are of
the Rongomaiwahine tribe which is, to my knowledge, the
only tribe in Aotearoa to have an eminent female ancestor
as Arikinui (chiefly) figurehead. Yet many, if not all,
Rongomaiwahine people have strong Kahungunu tribal connections.
Here at Nuhaka, we have a strong line of descendance from
the grandson of Kahungunu, whose name was Rakaipaaka.
Te Iwi o Rakaipaaka. The grandmother of Rakaipaaka was
Rongomaiwahine.
To the north are strong links to the peoples of Turanganui-a-Kiwa
(Gisborne), a shared waka (original canoe) in the form
of Takitimu, mythically guided to Aotearoa by the whale
Paikea. The waka Takitimu made its final rest at the settling
place of the aforementioned southern Ngai Tahu people.
The story of Paikea was recently presented to the world
on the silver screen in the internationally lauded "Whale
Rider" film. The story resounded for all New Zealanders
and for all Maori, but particularly so for the peoples
of the East Coast. The Takitimu was a sacred waka; all
its occupants from Hawaiki were Tohunga (spiritual seers),
all were male, and their journey here included strong
protocols of tikanga (belief systems) tapu (sacredness).
Takitimu was the "wairua waka" (sacred voyager)
for all the peoples of Aotearoa.
The Maori people of Aotearoa NZ now find themselves at
a profound point of social change -- and possible dislocation.
As a result of the Brash-fuelled controversy over foreshore
title, Maori are scapegoated as the ones with "special
rights" attempting to restrict the average Kiwi from
accessing beaches and coastline. Nobody is pointing out
that it is foreign ownership and skyrocketing property
prices that will ultimately transform our coastline and
resort areas (lakes and high country) into exclusive playgrounds
for the rich (mostly foreigners or wealthy immigrants).
How long before coastal "gated communities"
are developed across our country? It is Pakeha property
tycoons like John Spencer at Waiheke who seek strongly
to secure private beach access; not Maori. Not yet.
The stereotype is that Maori are lazy dole bludgers and
DPB addicts. Living on the East Coast, I would be the
first to readily admit that a high number of my people
live such lives. But many more do not. Being on the dole
is often seasonal in nature, with work on forestry, in
freezing works, and in horticulture taking up a fair chunk
of the year for a transitory labour force (there's also
the odd bit of "under the table" work). Up until
recently, local residents have had the luxury of a low
cost of living to work in such a transitional manner.
Skyrocketing coastal property prices threaten this, as
do changes in government policy.
It is truly ironic that the recently released list of
"No-Go" zones for unemployment beneficiaries
includes some of our nation's most high-priced coastal
localities. Take Hot Water Beach on the Coromandel. Is
there likely to be a flood of dole bludgers dropping out
to relocate there, what when the only beachfront sections
available are in the $900,000 to $1 million mark? Where
else is on the list? Let's try Pauanui and Ocean Beach.
* * * *
It is the worst of times, and it is the best of times.
Dr. Brash has unfortunately created a nasty racial split
in New Zealand in 2004, picked at the hardened-over (but
not yet healed) scab of New Zealand race relations that
last reared its ugly head during the Springbok Tour and
the Bastion Point occupation. The spectre of a right-wing
government that will roll back a whole series of progressive
social and economic programmes is clearly apparent. This
is the bad stuff, indeed.
The good stuff, is that division brings people together.
There is nothing like a common enemy for people in opposition
to such dire pathways to put aside their differences and
work to secure the future they want to see happen.
For the Left in New Zealand, it will mean a moderating
effect for relations between Labour and the Greens. Globally,
the Left has been energised by a common cause: opposition
to the global U.S. dictator-state lead by President George
W. Bush. It is now a year since millions around the world
marched in opposition to war in Iraq, in a wave of oppositional
energy not seen since the heady days of 1968. The centre
can hold; the centre must hold. Here in Aotearoa NZ, NZ
First must make its mark as a conservative party that
nevertheless recognises the fundamental place of Maori
to the identity of our nation (all "treaty gravy-train"-gates
aside). United Future also takes a fundamentally centric
position, socially conservative but nevertheless recognising
the importance of sound race relations for a sustainable
social future.
Politics is 51%. Over the past decade, we have moved
profoundly to a new political system in our country in
the form of Proportional Representation. This system has
resulted in the splintering of former political cores
(Labour and National) and a shift towards a negotiation-based
form of political operation. The idea of a Maori political
party raised in our media this past month has a significant
potential to make a real difference; to tip this political
balance to the required 51% mark to secure a centre-left
government in 2005; one that then must put Maori concerns
at the heart of it's policies.
Ironically, Brash's race-baiting has the potential to
embolden and draw together Maori visions of the future
of our country. The call by Tuariki Delamere and Derek
Fox to secure Maori party support from Dame Te Arikinui
Te Atairangikaahu (The Maori Queen) and preeminent Tuwharetoa
chief Sir Hepi Te Heuheu has the real potential to spur
a new political movement into reality.
Demographics and cultural influence are on the side of
Maori, if the existing MMP system stays in place.
Such a new political movement for Maori faces significant
challenges. There will be competing visions among Maori
for our economic and social development futures. Competing
value sets. Should we adopt mainstream western models
of economic success which promises a "McMaori"
social culture and has already eroded our tikanga? Or
should we all go "back to the land" and return
to our traditional communities that we were pushed out
of in the 1950s?
The reality is that the only option lies somewhere between
these two futures.
My perspective is that western economic development models
are both anathema to our communal culture, as well as
ecologically and socially unsustainable in the long-term.
Are Maori to become the handmaidens to a global tourism
and resort elite, with only a select few of us joining
the rich at the top?
I believe that Maori must base our plans for future economic
development on the "real world" -- a "RealPolitik"
approach according to Ngai Tahu intellectual Dr.
Te Maire Tau -- but that we must also focus on securing
a future that does not compromise the spirit of who we
are. Our Wairua. We must begin by examining the essentials
of who we are. We must commence important national dialogues
on the future of our Maori people, of our place in this
world, and our place in the future development of a shared
nationhood.
* * * *
"Kia mura tonu nga Ahi Kaa mo te matemateaone"
Keep the home fires burning so loved ones will always
return.
* * * *
I have found profound strength in returning to the Ahi
Kaa. After a time traversing the world, I have come back
to Nuhaka, to the birthplace of my tribe, to the homelands,
to look after my whanau and my tama and live daily life
among our wise kaumatua. I have found that this gives
me great strength, and a secure sense of identity.
Coming back to New Zealand was as much a "return
to the Ahi Kaa" as coming back to Nuhaka. Living
here, you immerse yourself daily in the nation's media,
in daily life and experience, and in shared social mores.
You travel the roads that all others travel, experience
the landscapes that all other see and the elements that
all others feel.
This gives us strength. This is what makes us truly unique.
Place matters.
The challenge for Maori is to harness the power of their
iwi, hapu and whanau ahi kaa identity, and marry this
to a sense of Aotearoa ahi kaa identity. Aotearoa New
Zealand's unique and authentic place in the world.
The challenge is to envision this future, and then set
about creating the world we want to see happen. The challenge
– for Pakeha as well as Maori – is to Envision Aotearoa.
GLOSSARY OF TERMS:
Ahi Kaa: The "home fires", the homelands.
"Yeah cuz, the putea's a bit erratic out here
on the coast and I've thought about goin' back to the
Big Smoke, but somebody's gotta keep the Ahi Kaa burning,
ya know?"
Faux Iwi: Pakeha who want to be Maori, highly
supportive of and well educated about Te Tiriti. Often
spotted wearing taonga (greenstone pendants). "Russell
looked all faux iwi pro at the barbie, decked out in his
oversized Pasifika print shirt matched with oversized
taonga and authentic Huffer jandals."
Hongi Snob: Maori establishment, often endeared
to British titles and in positions of important power
within Maoridom. "Dame Huia greeted the Governor
General with such grace and charm, her hongi snob deportment
told you who was really in charge. She was."
Putea: Money. As in, "Show me the Putea!"
****** ENDS ******